Refactor GetSourceType method#2182
Conversation
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Pull request overview
This PR refactors rule metadata to expose SourceType as a property rather than a GetSourceType() method, and renames the enum backing that metadata to RuleSourceType, updating the engine and built-in rules to match. The goal is to reduce boilerplate and standardize how built-in rules report their origin.
Changes:
- Replace
GetSourceType()implementations across built-in rules (and the rule template) with aSourceTypeproperty. - Rename
SourceTypeenum toRuleSourceTypeand updateIRule/RuleInfo/command plumbing accordingly. - Apply minor whitespace/formatting cleanups in touched rule files.
Reviewed changes
Copilot reviewed 83 out of 83 changed files in this pull request and generated 1 comment.
Show a summary per file
| File | Description |
|---|---|
| Utils/RuleMaker.psm1 | Updates the rule-generation template to emit the new SourceType property. |
| Rules/UseVerboseMessageInDSCResource.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/UseUTF8EncodingForHelpFile.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/UseUsingScopeModifierInNewRunspaces.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/UseToExportFieldsInManifest.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/UseSupportsShouldProcess.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/UseStandardDSCFunctionsInResource.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/UseSingularNouns.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/UseSingleValueFromPipelineParameter.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/UseShouldProcessForStateChangingFunctions.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/UseShouldProcessCorrectly.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/UsePSCredentialType.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/UseProcessBlockForPipelineCommand.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/UseOutputTypeCorrectly.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/UseLiteralInitializerForHashtable.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/UseIdenticalParametersDSC.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/UseIdenticalMandatoryParametersDSC.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/UseDeclaredVarsMoreThanAssignments.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/UseCorrectCasing.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override. |
| Rules/UseConstrainedLanguageMode.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/UseConsistentWhitespace.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/UseConsistentParametersKind.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override. |
| Rules/UseConsistentParameterSetName.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override. |
| Rules/UseConsistentIndentation.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/UseCompatibleCmdlets.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/UseCmdletCorrectly.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/UseBOMForUnicodeEncodedFile.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/UseApprovedVerbs.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/ReviewUnusedParameter.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/ReturnCorrectTypesForDSCFunctions.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/ProvideCommentHelp.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override. |
| Rules/PossibleIncorrectUsageOfRedirectionOperator.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/PossibleIncorrectUsageOfAssignmentOperator.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/PossibleIncorrectComparisonWithNull.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/PlaceOpenBrace.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override. |
| Rules/PlaceCloseBrace.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override. |
| Rules/MissingModuleManifestField.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/MisleadingBacktick.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/DscTestsPresent.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/DscExamplesPresent.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/CompatibilityRules/UseCompatibleSyntax.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override. |
| Rules/CompatibilityRules/CompatibilityRule.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override. |
| Rules/AvoidUsingWriteHost.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/AvoidUsingWMICmdlet.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/AvoidUsingPlainTextForPassword.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/AvoidUsingInvokeExpression.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override. |
| Rules/AvoidUsingDoubleQuotesForConstantString.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/AvoidUsingDeprecatedManifestFields.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/AvoidUsingConvertToSecureStringWithPlainText.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override. |
| Rules/AvoidUsingComputerNameHardcoded.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override. |
| Rules/AvoidUsingBrokenHashAlgorithms.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override. |
| Rules/AvoidUsingAllowUnencryptedAuthentication.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override. |
| Rules/AvoidUserNameAndPasswordParams.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/AvoidTrailingWhitespace.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/AvoidShouldContinueWithoutForce.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/AvoidSemicolonsAsLineTerminators.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override. |
| Rules/AvoidReservedWordsAsFunctionNames.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/AvoidReservedParams.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/AvoidReservedCharInCmdlet.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/AvoidPositionalParameters.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/AvoidOverwritingBuiltInCmdlets.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override. |
| Rules/AvoidNullOrEmptyHelpMessageAttribute.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/AvoidMultipleTypeAttributes.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/AvoidLongLines.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/AvoidInvokingEmptyMembers.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/AvoidGlobalVars.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/AvoidGlobalFunctions.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/AvoidGlobalAliases.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/AvoidExclaimOperator.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/AvoidEmptyCatchBlock.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/AvoidDefaultValueForMandatoryParameter.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/AvoidDefaultTrueValueSwitchParameter.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/AvoidAssignmentToAutomaticVariable.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property. |
| Rules/AvoidAlias.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() with SourceType property; whitespace cleanup. |
| Rules/AlignAssignmentStatement.cs | Replaces GetSourceType() override with SourceType override; whitespace cleanup. |
| Engine/Generic/RuleSourceType.cs | Renames the enum type from SourceType to RuleSourceType; updates doc comment. |
| Engine/Generic/RuleInfo.cs | Updates RuleInfo.SourceType and constructors to use RuleSourceType. |
| Engine/Generic/IRule.cs | Changes the rule contract from GetSourceType() to a SourceType property. |
| Engine/Generic/ExternalRule.cs | Updates external rule implementation to SourceType property. |
| Engine/Generic/ConfigurableRule.cs | Replaces abstract GetSourceType() with abstract SourceType property. |
| Engine/Generic/AvoidParameterGeneric.cs | Replaces abstract GetSourceType() with abstract SourceType property. |
| Engine/Generic/AvoidCmdletGeneric.cs | Replaces abstract GetSourceType() with abstract SourceType property. |
| Engine/Commands/GetScriptAnalyzerRuleCommand.cs | Switches to reading rule.SourceType when producing RuleInfo. |
Comments suppressed due to low confidence (1)
Engine/Generic/RuleSourceType.cs:10
- Renaming the public enum
SourceTypetoRuleSourceType(and changing the rule contract fromGetSourceType()to aSourceTypeproperty) is a breaking API change for any external rule implementations or consumers compiled against previous versions. If maintaining compatibility is required, consider keepingSourceType(or providing an[Obsolete]shim) and adding the new property/mapping without removing the old symbols until a major version bump.
💡 Add Copilot custom instructions for smarter, more guided reviews. Learn how to get started.
* Refactor GetSourceType method into one-liner using lambda operator. * Make code cleaner removing docstrings; The main one is provided in base IRule interface. * Unify GetSourceType method implementation across all rules.
dd25a91 to
23c7f9e
Compare
bergmeister
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
since the only value of this is to reduce number of lines of code and there are still many others methods left, it leaves state after this PR inconsistent. I think we have to make a decision first whether we want to go through this or not @andyleejordan and if so we need to do it all in one go
operator.
provided in base IRule interface.
PR Summary
Motivation:
I consider these changes useful, because such refactoring allows to reduce the total amount of code in the rules, thereby the developer will be more focused on the logic of the rule itself. In the future, it is planned to complete refactoring with other common methods for the rules.
PR Checklist
.cs,.ps1and.psm1files have the correct copyright headerWIP:to the beginning of the title and remove the prefix when the PR is ready.